Painful exercise has no clear advantage in chronic musculoskeletal pain
In adults with persistent muscle, bone or joint pain, a review found no clear difference between painful and nonpainful exercise. Weak evidence leaves both benefit and harm uncertain.
Based on the published abstract. The full paper may contain additional methods, results and limitations.
The 30-second takeaway
For adults with chronic musculoskeletal pain, the review did not detect differences in pain intensity or disability between painful and nonpainful exercise across the reported follow-up periods. However, wide uncertainty intervals and low confidence in the evidence mean these findings cannot establish that the approaches are equally effective or equally safe.
Every included trial had a high risk of bias, and evidence certainty ranged from very low to low. The wide confidence intervals leave room for differences that the available studies could not resolve.
What researchers found
Painful versus nonpainful exercise
Pooled trial results did not detect a difference over short, medium or long follow-up. Exact time windows and effect estimates were not supplied; confidence intervals were wide.
What the review compared
The researchers brought together trials directly comparing exercise that hurt with exercise that did not. Pain intensity and disability were central outcomes, alongside participants' reports of quality of life, mood and other experiences.
Why uncertainty matters
Confidence intervals describe uncertainty around an estimated difference. Here, they were wide, while the trials had substantial methodological concerns. Similar reported results for adverse events therefore do not establish that the approaches have identical safety.
The original publication
Effectiveness of Painful Versus Nonpainful Exercise on Pain Intensity, Disability, and Other Patient-Reported Outcomes in Adults With Chronic Musculoskeletal Pain: An Updated Systematic Review With Meta-Analysis.
Tran I, Gibbs MT, Yu N et al.
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther · 2025
- PubMed ID
- 40699606
- Record checked
AI-assisted research and writing. This explains one selected publication; it is not a complete review of everything known. Our approach.
One more question, understood.
Keep track of the research you’ve explored.